Notre Dame quarterback Riley Leonard has been a pivotal force behind the Fighting Irish’s impressive 14-1 record, leading them to the national championship game. His performance this season, amassing 3,472 total yards and accounting for 35 touchdowns, has garnered significant attention. Among the most notable is a comparison made by sports commentator Colin Cowherd, who likened Leonard to NFL All-Pro quarterback Josh Allen.

The Basis for the Comparison

Standing at nearly 6-foot-4 and weighing 216 pounds, Leonard possesses a physical stature reminiscent of Allen. His athleticism is evident, with recorded 40-yard dash times in the 4.5-second range, showcasing both speed and physicality. This combination allows Leonard to excel in both passing and rushing situations, making him a dual-threat on the field. 

Cowherd’s comparison likely stems from these physical attributes and Leonard’s ability to impact the game in multiple facets, much like Allen does for the Buffalo Bills. Both quarterbacks have demonstrated the capability to extend plays with their legs and make challenging throws, adding a dynamic element to their respective offenses.

Scrutiny and Skepticism

Despite the flattering comparison, some analysts and fans view it as premature. Leonard’s journey to this point has been marked by both achievements and areas needing improvement. Transferring from Duke to Notre Dame, he has faced critiques regarding his consistency and decision-making under pressure. Skeptics argue that while his athleticism is undeniable, equating him to a proven NFL talent like Allen may set unrealistic expectations.

Discussions on platforms like Reddit reflect a range of opinions, with some fans expressing reservations about Leonard’s readiness to be compared to top-tier NFL quarterbacks. Concerns about his passing accuracy and ability to perform against elite defenses are common themes among critics. 

Leonard’s Perspective and Future Prospects

Leonard himself has acknowledged areas for growth, particularly in refining his passing mechanics and decision-making. His self-awareness and commitment to improvement have been evident throughout the season, as he has worked to adapt to Notre Dame’s offensive schemes and elevate his performance.

Looking ahead, Leonard’s focus remains on leading the Fighting Irish to a national championship victory. A strong performance on such a significant stage could bolster his prospects for a future in the NFL. However, he remains grounded, understanding that development is a continuous process, and success at the collegiate level does not automatically translate to professional stardom.

Conclusion

While comparisons to NFL players like Josh Allen can be flattering, they also come with heightened expectations. Riley Leonard’s athleticism and contributions to Notre Dame’s successful season are commendable, but equating him to an established NFL All-Pro may be premature. As Leonard continues to develop his skills and gain experience, he has the potential to carve out his own unique path in football. For now, fans and analysts alike should appreciate his current achievements while allowing him the space to grow without the burden of lofty comparisons.